Shards Casual Draft

It's Christmastime, and that means that many of my friends are back in town for a few weeks. One of my friends, Greg, plays Magic, and has some friends who play too. So, we decided to set up a Shards draft. It occurred last night.

There were only four of us: me, Greg, Dave, and Eric. Greg and Dave had done Shards sealed once, and Eric had never seen Shards before, so I had a considerable experience advantage going into the draft, for what it's worth. I opened my packs, as usual, based on the art: first the Steward of Valeron pack, then Godsire, then Sedris, the Traitor King.

My first pack's rare was Mycoloth, but the pack also contained Bone Splinters and Oblivion Ring. There was hardly any white in the pack, though, so I decided not to take Oblivion ring, and instead took Bone Splinters. I figured, if I didn't take it, someone else would, and if one of us had Mycoloth and the other had Bone Splinters, I'd rather be the one with the Splinters. A good choice? I don't know. But we'll see.

I gradually edged my way into Grixis, taking lots and lots of removal early on, with hardly any creatures until the end of my second pack. My second pack's rare was Hellkite Overlord, which I obviously had to take, but I didn't want to splash green to play it, so it stayed in my sideboard, safely out of Greg's reach (he was playing Jund, and his first pick was Kresh the Bloodbraided). Greg was seated to my right, Eric playing Bant/Esper to my left, and Dave's Naya across from me. So there wasn't a huge amount of competition for cards.

I got a Cruel Ultimatum passed to me in the third pack. I knew how amazing the Ultimatum was, but they didn't, so they didn't hate-draft it before I could snatch it up in my grimy claws. There were a ton of Grixis uncommons, which was awesome for me. I also got a Covenant of Minds, and…well, here's my decklist:

40 Cards (I counted this time)

17 LANDS
1 Crumbling Necropolis
5 Island
5 Mountain
6 Swamp

15 CREATURES
1 Blood Cultist
2 Fatestitcher
1 Hissing Iguanar
1 Kathari Screecher
1 Kederekt Creeper
1 Rockslide Elemental
1 Scourge Devil
1 Shore Snapper
1 Skeletal Kathari
1 Tidehollow Strix
1 Undead Leotau
1 Viscera Dragger
2 Vithian Stinger

8 OTHER SPELLS
1 Bone Splinters
1 Call to Heel
1 Covenant of Minds
1 Cruel Ultimatum
2 Grixis Charm
1 Infest
1 Obelisk of Grixis

2 SIDEBOARD CARDS I USED
2 Swerve

Awesome. Now on to the games. With only four of us, we just did round robin, with victory going to whoever had the best record. I played Greg first.

Greg had a lot of 1 toughness dudes, which fell swiftly to my Blood Cultist. He didn't draw Kresh, but it would hardly have mattered – a Fatestitcher locked down all his good stuff while I attacked with my fliers and Creeper. Covenant of Minds proved to be awesome, and I used Grixis Charm's red mode (+2/+0 to all my creatures) more than the others. He didn't stand much of a chance.

The second game, I got to play Cruel Ultimatum. The outcome of that game should be obvious. I beat Greg 2-0.

Then I played Dave's aggressive Naya deck. Wild Nacatl beat me down quite a bit before I managed to get rid of it, and he kept playing threats, but eventually I played Cruel Ultimatum and, well, you know the rest.

The second game, I found out who had ended up with the Mycoloth. It was Dave. It was wrecking me until I finally managed to Infest all his Saprolings and then Call to Heel the Mycoloth. But he got more dudes and devoured them again, and I couldn't remove it. I died.

The third game, I drew Cruel Ultimatum again. I beat Dave 2-1.

Then I had to play Eric. Eric isn't a spectacular player, but he's a much better deckbuilder than Greg and Dave. The first game, his big Esper dudes (Cloudheath Drakes and Steelclad Serpents) plus his sneaky Deft Duelists cause me a lot of trouble, especially since he backed them up with a lot of good defense - Hindering Light, Resounding Wave, and Call to Heel. I kept trying to remove his Drakes, only to have him bounce them and play them again. And his Metallurgeon didn't make things any easier. I couldn't stop his swarm of fliers, and I died.

The second game was epic. My removal was a bit more effective, but this time I got some Vithian Stingers and Fatestitchers out. I kept tapping down his big guys and removing whoever I could, and then pinging him for one or two at the end of each of his turns. He couldn't attack into my Kederekt Creeper and Undead Leotau, and I kept removing any flier he'd play, or keeping it tapped with a Fatestitcher. I won that game by pinging him to death. I never attacked with a single creature.

The third game was much the same as the first. I died. Eric defeated me 2-1.

So my record was 5-3. Dave's was also 5-3, Eric's 4-3, and Greg's 1-6 (poor Greg). Dave and I played a tiebreaker game…during which I played Cruel Ultimatum. That card is truly a game-winner.

In retrospect, I should have kept Shore Snapper in my sideboard in favor of Swerve, because I had to keep switching the Snapper out whenever I played an opponent with no Islands (which was 2/3 of them). I never actually got to play Swerve, but it certainly would have been useful if I had had it in some of my game 1's. In the second game against Eric, I actually sideboarded Infest out, because his dudes were all bigger than mine, so it would rarely have been useful. Still, I was pretty happy with how my deck ended up. Fatestitcher is an insanely powerful card in limited, and I had two of them. Those guys and Cruel Ultimatum are probably what won me most of my games.

So anyway, I won (woohoo!), and the prizes at our little draft were to divvy up the rares. We all took the rares out of our decks and placed them on the table to pick which ones we wanted. The rares were:

Brilliant Ultimatum
Covenant of Minds
Cruel Ultimatum
Gather Specimens
Hellkite Overlord
Keeper of Progenitus
Knight-Captain of Eos
Kresh the Bloodbraided
Manaplasm
Minion Reflector
Mycoloth
Sharding Sphinx

I got to pick two first, so I took Cruel Ultimatum and Sharding Sphinx. I don't remember the exact order and picks of everyone, but I ended up with Mycoloth and Knight-Captain of Eos. Not bad. My Esper deck could use a second Sphinx, and I may now have enough cards to build a decent Grixis deck, or at least augment my new Jund deck.

We then played Greg's Battlestar Galactica board game, which was pretty funny. Greg kept throwing people in the Brig. The phrase "throw ___ in the BRIG!" was shouted many, many times. But the Cylons won, because Greg threw me in the Brig, but I wasn't actually a Cylon, so I was powerless to stop treacherous Cylon Dave from depleting all of our fuel. Jerk.

Greg and co. will be around for a while, and they enjoy drafts, so hopefully I'll get to draft some more in the coming weeks. Casual drafts are nice; no one yells at you if you say what card you picked, or if you look at your drafted cards during a round. No one shuffles your deck 2420934 times and counts your deck to see if it has 40 cards. And best of all, no one hate-drafts Cruel Ultimatum! :D